Dublin Zoo I

Dublin Zoo

Dublin Zoo was opened to the public on the 1st September 1831 with 46 mammals and 72 birds on display, all donated by London Zoo. The entry charge was sixpence that later was reduced to one penny on Sundays. It was basically a shed with the animal cages housed in a random order. The animals were routinely taunted and abused by the visitors. During the Famine of the 1840 many animals died and the institution almost collapsed. Another tough time was in the end of the 1980’s. The zoo was struggling and the council considered closing it, but with the aid of the Government it eventually started to recover. At present, Dublin Zoo is a home to some 400 animals.

I am going to the Dublin Zoo once in a decade. I have mixed feelings about the Zoos, especially about breeding in captivity. This time there were three baby elephants born within a year.

This little baby bull elephant Kabir was born to mama Yasmin in May. He is Yasmin’s fourth calf.

Dublin Zoo

Dublin Zoo

Dublin Zoo

The other two baby elephants are Zinda born in September 2016 and Avani born in March this year, both girls.

Zinda’s mum Asha was the first Asian elephant born in Dublin Zoo back in 2007, the year of my previous visit (picture below). She was hiding behind her mother and I had a hard time taking a good picture of her.

dublin zoo 2007

Asha’s mum and Zinda’s grandmother Bernhardine is still alive. She is the matriarch of the herd.

Dublin Zoo’s first elephant was a female called Sita, and her keeper was James McNally. In 1903 Sita cut her foot and as James was applying ointment to her wound, she knocked him down with her trunk and stamped on his head. The coroner decided she had acted out of malice and sentenced her to death. Nearly 30 years of good behavior prior the accident didn’t help, and after two days an experienced elephant hunter and a firing squad did the killing. Even McNally’s son said that his father would not have wanted the animal killed.

Sita’s stamping foot was preserved as an umbrella bucket in the Zoo cafeteria for decades.

I didn’t have a good view of the other babies – you see Zinda in the middle and Avani on the left. They look happy, but their future is unclear.

Dublin Zoo

Another set of cute babies –  Tamworth piglets.

Dublin Zoo

Dublin Zoo

Dublin Zoo

Not a baby anymore but still good looking 😉

Dublin Zoo

African Red river hog, shy nocturnal animal with long tufted ears.

Dublin Zoo

Just a billy goat from the Family Farm.

Dublin Zoo

Bored chicken from the Family Farm.

Dublin Zoo

Southern white rhino, endangered species. They have a big herd here in Dublin Zoo, and a male calf was born last August.

Dublin Zoo

More than 100 animals died at Dublin Zoo during the 24 month period from 2014 to 2016, among them Southern white rhinoceros, two Rothschild giraffes, three grey wolves and a red panda.

Rothschild giraffes in 2007. They are no more.

dublin zoo 2007

Red panda in 2007. Gone.

dublin zoo 2007

Humboldt penguins are very quiet. Ten years ago there were more of them, and I remember the sounds they made – trumpet-like, even elephant-like.

Dublin Zoo

This picture is 10 years old. Three Humboldt penguins died in 2015. There are fewer than 12000 of the penguins left in the wild..

Dublin zoo 2007

Penguins and zebras look good in monochrome pictures.

Dublin Zoo

Dublin Zoo

I love these neat animals.

Dublin Zoo

Another black & white favorite – European magpies. They are living in the zoo along with many other wild birds including a Grey heron. I saw him in 2007 and he is still alive, still hanging with penguins and probably stealing their fish 🙂

Dublin Zoo

Here are some links you might be interested in:

National Animal Rights Association, Ireland

Captive Animals’ Protection Society (CAPS)

Thank you for visiting Dublin Zoo with me. One more post next Saturday.

inesemjphotography Have a wonderful weekend!

81 comments

  1. Like many of the commenters here, I do not like zoos. They are outdated and horrid places for animals. I believe animals are on earth for their own purposes not ours. Man has exploited them to death, literally. Many excuses are made as to why they still exist, I don’t believe any of them are good excuses. Rescuing and rehabilitating animals is a much better system. I pray for a better world for all animals. Your photo’s are wonderful.

    Like

  2. So many of us have mixed feelings about zoos, Inese. Some claim to be breeding very endangered species, which can be later released into the wild. Jersey Zoo (on the island of Jersey, established by Gerald Durrell) is one of those. We visited there in 1998. I don’t know how it’s faring nowadays, so I’ll have to look that up, but it did claim success with several species in the 90s.
    The mortality rates you quote for Dublin Zoo are disturbing and I imagine they may be similar to other zoos. All early zoos were horrendous places, purely for the entertainment of people without a care for the animals there. However good a zoo is nowadays, I still feel those animals would be far better off in their natural habitats – unless the zoo is attempting to prevent extinction of the species.
    There are always so many feelings roused over this issue. Thank you for the thought-provoking post and gorgeous photos, Inese. I’ll read Part II asap.

    Like

    1. Thank you! I think elephant is one of the most zoo-tolerant animals. If there is food, elephant will stay close and feel happy 🙂 What worries me is that they breed elephants to attract visitors, but how many elephants one can afford to keep? Where the rest will go? There were rumors that some of them go to the animal circuses 😦

      Like

  3. These animals have safety and some quality in their lives. Not all animals belong in zoos but by displaying wildlife, people who may never ba able to see coral reefs, islands with sea turtles, nor lions with their mates and young living together may never know how important it is to use good ecological choices, preserving nature isn’t one learned from books but from actually seeing living examples. I understand some may feel these animals suffer and feel constrained. Conservation and donations are needed for this world to keep on going. . .
    Sorry, Inese, I support humane treatment and believe most zoos do care and try to help. 🕊
    Soon, I want to share my giraffe photos from the Columbus Zoo, while my grandies hold lettuce leaves and giraffes come up and gobble them up!
    We have acres in an area which are called “the Wilds” down south of Columbus, Ohio. Some of the giraffes come to live in our safari area of our Columbus Zoo. They run, gallop and seem so happy and free. I hope someday that I will share my pictures in the (boring) winter. xo 💐 Smiles, Robin

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Robin, I don’t argue, some zoos are good. Dublin Zoo had death rate 11% in 2015 – do you think it is normal? Almost 160 animals died in Fota Island in 2015. I wrote about Fota, genuinely though it was a great place. Now I only have photographs, the animals are gone. It is all wrong, it shouldn’t be like that.

      Liked by 1 person

      1. I do feel concern and noticed you included the 11% statistics, Inese. I think that WWF might like to check into this.
        I definitely see you as an advocate and hope someone who knows how to get them involved may read your fine posts. Your photography and heartfelt words mean a lot to me and others.
        The World Wildlife Foundation says they look into conservation of wildlife and endangered species. They wish for harmony between nature and mankind. Just a possible lead. . .

        Liked by 1 person

  4. I love your photos of the animals and birds. I am also on the fence when it comes to zoos, I don’t like seeing the animals in small spaces but if the zoo is a good one and they make sure the animals are well cared for, it could mean the species still exists when there are few/none left in the wild. Not ideal. Some zoos do it much better than others. Love Gill xxxxx

    Liked by 1 person

  5. I have some misgivings about Zoos, too. However, I really love going to the Toronto Zoo. So I have decided to take the philosophy that Zoos help people to care about the animals and by extension their natural habitats in the native lands.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thank you for your comment! I would say – everything depends on the living conditions. If animals get sick and feel stressed out in their enclosures, I am not a supporter of such zoo. If animals have been rescued from circuses or traffickers and housed in a happier environment, then it sounds like a right thing to me.

      Like

  6. Beautiful pictures, as always, Inese! Those elephant babys are so very lovely! I could watch them playing and fooling around all day. 😄 The BBC has made some wonderful documentaries about them in the wild. Since we’ve already talked about these mixed feelings when I posted about the Berlin Zoo, I won’t repeat it here now. But I was quite shocked reading about the Dublin Zoo’s difficulties in the past and present. The loss of so many in such a short time in the last years let’s an epidemic come mind… But the surviving ones look very healthy and well cared for. 😄
    Thank you for taking us to the Zoo this time! It’s wonderful how many things I’ve learned about your corner of the world through you and your beautiful posts and pictures! 😄 xxxxxxxxxx

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thank you so much, Sarah! I cannot tell exactly what had happened, but something was definitely wrong since the mortality rate was at about 11-12% these years. I hope they improved their veterinary care. In my second blog I will write about more cases… As I see it, something isn’t quite right with their vet department. xxxxxxxxxxxxx

      Like

  7. Love the photos but I also have mixed feelings about zoos. I remember reading a book about the popular menageries and what a show it used to be to bring wild animals to Europe centuries ago. (I love the farms one can visit with kids and not so kids…) 🙂

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thank you Olga! I wouldn’t mind the zoos if I knew that animals were happy there. Not all the animals can live in captivity and stay sane. You are so right mentioning the farms. These animals are domesticated and food is the main factor. I could say the same about elephants, but I hate to see cheetah or tigers locked in their cages. It is so very sad.

      Like

  8. Your photos are glorious! 🙂 🙂 It’s another difficult issue, isn’t it? Life seems full of them sometimes. Most of the zoos do great conservation work but it doesn’t seem right to see these lovely creatures in captivity.

    Liked by 2 people

    1. Thank you for your comment! During my visit I had notice some alarming factors – heavy commercialization; absence of some animals who were there before; enclosures overgrown with unkempt bushes. When I returned home I started doing my research and found more facts. Most of animals can live in captivity just fine. Everything depends on the living conditions and care, and it is where the problems lie.

      Liked by 1 person

  9. Although I don’t attend zoos, I don’t have a problem with them as long as they’re managed humanely, or breeding programs – especially for endangered species. Our local zoo is known for success in its elephant program, including having the first successful birth in the USA in 44 years back in 1962. As for the captivity thing, I think many people think that living in the wild is analogous to living in the Garden of Eden – an easy, long-lived, low-stress life. I suspect that reality is far from that perception, and the mortality rate is much higher than that of a well-managed zoo.

    Liked by 2 people

    1. Dave, you are hundred percent right. In the wild, their life is generally short. But it doesn’t excuse bad veterinary care, drugging, unsuitable housing, lack of privacy, and some other bad practices that occur in the zoos. If the humans interfere and take an animal out of its habitat, they also take on responsibility. I go to the zoo on my granddaughters’ birthday every year. If controlled and monitored, the zoos can become a refuges for endangered species and a source of education. With no proper control things get out of hand.

      Liked by 1 person

    1. The same here. I think it is only acceptable when the animals do need help. Also, behind the scenes there are many dark secrets hiding, like drugging animals, selling them to the circuses etc. Of course the things are getting better every year, or at least I hope so..

      Liked by 1 person

    1. Thank you Derrick. I visit every year with my granddaughters. It is a huge area of concern, but the requirements are getting tougher every year, and some zoos have to be closed down. There are too many captive animals in the world, and it takes a long time before majority of the establishments cease to exist. Until then, the animals need our entrance fees.

      Liked by 1 person

  10. I would strongly agree with James McNally about putting down Sita after the incident. We can’t know whether there was any intent by Sita. If this was a case between humans then there would be investigation and trial in an attempt for fairness to both sides. I like visiting zoo when I was a young child and but now I have different opinion about zoo. I do not mind visit zoo but in the back of my mind, I always wonder about how animals feel about being in confinement. Of course, some that are born in captivity may not know any difference but still.

    Love your farm chickens and the B & W Zebra pictures. They are really nice.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thank you so much! The times have changed since that accident, but similar things still happen, which only means that a wild animal has to be treated as such, with care and precautions. I wish these young elephants were moved to their habitats some day, but the poachers would hunt them down as they would be an easy target.

      Liked by 1 person

  11. That is a bitter-sweet account of the zoo, a bit alarming too, if you think of the deaths. The family of elephants has Indian names except for the matriarch. We grew up with stories of miffed elephants crushing their mahouts. There was the account of the penitent felon who fell into a mourning after killing its keeper and eventually starved itself to death. As children, every time we saw a tusker ambling down the road we gave it a wide berth. But they were objects of awe nonetheless, enormous in size, and graceful in their swinging gait. Those are cute photographs, even if sad as they don’t grace the earth any more.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thank you so much, Uma! Yes, they gave the names on purpose.
      Elephant, if fed well, doesn’t suffer much in captivity. Unfortunately, many zoos secretly sell the young elephants to the circuses. I would start with entirely sweeping the animal circuses off the face of the earth, and then see what can be done with the zoos – like ensuring transparency in all their dealings with animals.

      Like

    1. I too. The elephants don’t need too much space though, but they do need the option of retiring to their sleeping area when they are tired of visitors. Unfortunately, it is a common practice to keep the doors locked so that the visitors could see them all the time. Very few zoos respect the elephants rights for privacy.

      Liked by 1 person

    1. Thank you David! Yes, there are many zoos who are doing much worse. The zoos can become a better place if there is control and transparency. People are not honest dealing with each other – how can we expect them being honest dealing with animals. Many hugs xxxxxx

      Liked by 1 person

  12. A fine sharing, Inese, thank you.
    Like you, i have mixed feelings about zoos in general but with so many animals facing extinction and their habitats being take away by the day a zoo may be the only place for some of them to survive.

    Much love to you

    john

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thank you so much, John. You are right of course, but there is that ‘human factor’… Humans love money, and don’t love responsibility. As I already said, strict control and transparency can make the zoos a safe refuge. Until then all imaginable bad practices still take place.
      Sorry I was not online too often this summer.
      Sending love

      Like

  13. Not sure how to feel about your zoo. The animals appear to be happy. I do not feel bad about visiting zoos as it gives lots of people, especially children a chance to see the animals, but only if the zoo is well-maintained and funded. It is not like a circus where the animals are used for entertainment. Most of our zoos have very natural backgrounds for the animals and they are not in little cages. I wonder if the harsh weather in Ireland causes a lot of hardship for animals used to warmer climates. Anyway, loved the images – the baby elephants are really cute.

    Liked by 2 people

    1. I too don’t feel bad about visiting the zoo. At least we add to the funds. I feel bad when I see unnatural behavior, like pacing, which only means that the animal is stressed out and mentally exhausted. On my previous visit I felt heartbroken about the gorillas. They had no personal space at all. Poor Harry the silverback would sit there with his back turned to the visitors. I also hate when the animals are forced to stay out of their houses just to please the visitors. I’d rather the zoos kept the rescued animals who cannot live in the wild anymore. Death rate in the Zoos is too high. Data statistics is available on the internet.
      Another zoo I am visiting with my daughters once a year is Utah’s Hogle Zoo. It is accredited by the Association of Zoos and abides by strict laws.

      Liked by 1 person

  14. Mixed feelings, or not, and I do too, your capture of these animals on camera is brilliant as ever, although I would love to put your pictures side by side of images taken by you in the wild. I bet these magnificent creatures wouldn’t look quite so sad xxxxx

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thank you 🙂 One of the very few animals that feel more or less alright in the zoo is elephant. Elephants stay where their food is, but most of the other animals get very depressed in time. Some of them develop severe mental illness. 😦 xxxxxx

      Liked by 2 people

  15. Totally against Zoos unless the animals cannot live in the wild due to life threatening injuries of sorts. Love those piglets could put those in my pocket and go home with them and those birds can sit on my shoulder whenever they want they are all beautiful photos

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thank you so much! I absolutely agree with you. If an animal is rescued, saved from irresponsible owner, then it can be held in the zoo as long as it lives. Breeding in the zoo is all wrong. Take the elephants to their natural habitat and let them breed there, give the young a chance to return to where they belong.

      Liked by 2 people

Thank you for leaving a comment!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s